Whose depiction of macbeth—shakespeare’s or holinshed’s—is more interesting or compelling from a reader’s standpoint? why?

I think its Shakespeare's version of Macbeth. In Shakespeare's  version,  you can see the mask that Macbeth wears. Many people can see him as a good person in this version, you can also see how he is when he is consumed by paranoia and greed for power. 

The answer would be c. logical because it is explaining how the device is tempting which makes it logical