(1) edgar allan poe wrote the short story “the tell-tale heart.” (2) poe wrote the story in 1843. (3) in the story, a man is haunted by an old man’s eye. (4) he thinks it looks like the eye of a vulture. (5) we soon learn that the haunted man has a mysterious disease. (6) the disease has made the man insane. (7) he does not know it. (8) for seven nights, he sneaks into the old man’s room. (9) he watches the sleeping man. (10) i will not tell you what happens next because i do not want to spoil the story for you. which is the most effective way to combine sentences (1) and (2)? edgar allan poe wrote the short story “the tell-tale heart,” and he wrote it in 1843. “the tell-tale heart,” written in 1843, is a short story and by poe. edgar allan poe wrote the short story “the tell-tale heart” in 1843. in 1843, edgar allan poe wrote the tell-tale heart,” and it is a short story.