Read this student’s draft. Coastal towns should protect themselves from floods by building sand walls that keep out water from oceans, lakes, and rivers. However, some say that these sand walls are an eyesore. They reduce the value of the homes and buildings that they try to protect because they look bad.

Now, identify a rebuttal that the writer uses to address the counterclaim.

The value of the homes is more important than oceans, lakes, and rivers.
The protection of homes and buildings in coastal towns with sand walls is important.
Sand walls may be ugly, but the protection of people and property is more important.

The harlem renaissance dawned in an era of pervasive racism and segregation. although legally "free," many african americans were still bound by ideas that had their roots in the slavery of earlier centuries. identity and freedom are important ideas presented in many of the poems from the harlem renaissance. furthermore, the values of identity and freedom are not unique to particular times and places. as hughes expresses in "dream variations," all humans want to be able to develop their identities in freedom. what role does freedom play in the poems you read in this unit? what is required of a society to enable each individual to be true to his or her identity and be free to live by that identity? write about at least three of the poems, describing how the poet uses imagery to depict freedom and identity, the lack of it, or the desire for it.